The article examines the evolution of the relationship between the Italian legal system and the European Convention on Human Rights since the Italian Constitutional Court’s landmark “twin judgments” of 2007, focusing on the authority of the European Court of Human Rights’ case law within the domestic legal system. Against the background of the transformations affecting the Convention system during the age of subsidiarity and the procedural turn, the paper reconstructs the main stages of Italian constitutional case law: from the integration of the ECHR as an interposed norm, to the development of techniques for selecting Strasbourg precedents, and finally to the more recent non-defensive and incremental understanding of the margin of appreciation. The analysis highlights the growing role of the Constitutional Court as the domestic guarantor of Convention rights within a framework of shared responsibility between national legal systems and the ECHR system.
L'ordinamento italiano e la CEDU nella age of subsidiarity. Un bilancio della giurisprudenza costituzionale
Giorgio Repetto
2026
Abstract
The article examines the evolution of the relationship between the Italian legal system and the European Convention on Human Rights since the Italian Constitutional Court’s landmark “twin judgments” of 2007, focusing on the authority of the European Court of Human Rights’ case law within the domestic legal system. Against the background of the transformations affecting the Convention system during the age of subsidiarity and the procedural turn, the paper reconstructs the main stages of Italian constitutional case law: from the integration of the ECHR as an interposed norm, to the development of techniques for selecting Strasbourg precedents, and finally to the more recent non-defensive and incremental understanding of the margin of appreciation. The analysis highlights the growing role of the Constitutional Court as the domestic guarantor of Convention rights within a framework of shared responsibility between national legal systems and the ECHR system.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


